GAX Roofing crew relaying flat concrete tile over new self-adhered underlayment on the lower front roof section of a Huntington Beach home
Homeowner Guide

Spot Repair or
the Full Facet?

There are two honest ways to fix a roof leak. We recommend the full facet, we'll do a spot repair when that's what the roof calls for, and we tell you straight which one it is.

Get a Free Estimate →
✓ C39 Licensed & Insured
◈ Free In-Home Estimates
⌂ Owner Runs Every Job
◐ Se Habla Espanol
Start here

The Short Answer

A spot repair fixes the one place the water gets in. A full facet redoes one whole plane of the roof, between a ridge and an edge or a valley. We recommend the full facet, because it actually fixes the problem on that plane. We'll do a spot repair when that's what the roof calls for. Either way we find the source first, and we tell you straight which one your roof needs.

A spot repair fits when

  • It is one problem on a roof that's otherwise sound
  • The cause is isolated: one failed pipe boot, a few shingles off after a wind, a tile that slipped or broke
  • The underlayment is sound

The full facet fits when

  • One plane of the roof is in bad shape and the rest is decent
  • A patch would leave old material in the middle of that plane
First

Find the Source Before You Scope Anything

The drip in your ceiling is almost never where the water gets in. Water enters at a flashing, a pipe seal or a slipped tile, then travels along the underlayment and framing before it shows, sometimes ten feet from the entry point. A patch placed over the stain can be flawless work and still miss the hole completely.

So the scope comes second. First we find where the water really enters.

Listen first

Where it shows up, whether it is every rain or only the big ones, and how long it has been going on. In my experience the homeowner knows more about that leak than I do when I pull up.

Instruments point

A thermal camera reads wet material colder than dry material, so the suspect area shows up on screen. The camera sees temperature, not water.

People confirm

We go into the attic and find the same spot from below, then follow the wet path to where the water actually enters. That is where the repair goes.

At GAXOn a repair call we bring the thermal camera and confirm from the attic when we can. The repair is documented with photos you keep. More in how we find a roof leak.
A ceiling that looks clean beside its thermal frame showing a cold mass of wet material during an Inland Empire roof leak inspection
The ceiling looks clean. The thermal frame beside it shows the cold, wet area.
Dark water staining along a rafter found from the attic during a leak inspection in Azusa, CA
Azusa, CA: the attic confirmed it.
Option 1

What a Spot Repair Is

A spot repair fixes the one place the water gets in, and nothing more. One problem on a healthy roof is a repair.

What it looks like

A pipe boot or a vent collar replaced. A few shingles the wind took, put back. A slipped or broken tile reset or swapped. A flashing that failed, redone.

When it holds

When the roof is in good shape and the underlayment is sound. A good repair on a roof like that buys real years.

When it doesn't

When it is aimed at the stain and not the source. Most failed repairs are not bad work. They are good patches in the wrong place.

Valley metal with a raised center rib back in over new Spyder PSU underlayment on a tile roof in Rancho Cucamonga, CA
Rancho Cucamonga, CA: a leak fixed at its source, the valley. New underlayment under the valley metal, then the same tile back on.
Option 2

What a Full Facet Is

A facet is one plane of the roof, between a ridge and an edge or a valley. A full facet means we redo that whole plane instead of patching it.

  1. The roofing on that plane comes off

    On a tile roof, the tile comes off and gets stacked, because it is going back on.

  2. The deck gets cleared

    With the plane open we can see the wood. Decking that is damaged or rotted gets replaced.

  3. New underlayment runs the whole plane

    Top to eave, with nothing old left in the middle of it.

  4. The roofing goes back on

    On tile, the same tile goes back on when it is still good, and nobody can tell from the street.

At GAXIn Huntington Beach we did the lower front section this way: the tile came off and got stacked, the deck was cleared, new self-adhered underlayment ran the whole section, wall to eave, and the same tile went back on.
Aerial view of a roof repair in Huntington Beach, CA: flat concrete tile lifted and stacked on the lower front section, new Spyder PSU self-adhered underlayment down, GAX Roofing truck in the driveway
Huntington Beach, CA: the whole lower front section opened up, not a patch.
Our recommendation

Why We Recommend the Full Facet

When a plane of the roof is the problem, we recommend redoing the whole plane. It costs more than a patch and less than a full replacement, and it actually fixes the problem on that plane. A full facet repair comes with a 4-year limited workmanship warranty.

Nothing old left in the middle

New underlayment runs the whole plane. A patch covers one spot.

We get to see the deck

You can't see the deck until the roofing is off. With the plane open, rotted wood gets found and replaced, not covered.

A leak is a path, not a spot

Water enters at one point and travels along the underlayment before it shows. That is why a patch aimed at the stain misses so often.

At GAXThis is a recommendation, not a rule. If a spot repair is what your roof calls for, that is what we'll write up.
New OSB decking installed where the rotted wood was cut out on a Hemet tile roof repair
Hemet, CA: sealant on top didn't stop the leak. With the tile up, the rotted deck was cut out and replaced.
Which one

What You See and What It Usually Means

We don't upsell a bigger job when a repair will do. The key word is isolated. This is what usually holds, not a rule. The roof gets the final say once somebody is up there looking at it.

What you seeWhat it usually meansWhat we'd do
One leak after a wind, a few shingles off, or one failed pipe boot, on a roof that's otherwise soundAn isolated problemA spot repair, at the spot where the water gets in
A slipped or broken tile, on a tile roof that's otherwise soundAn isolated problemA spot repair: reset or swap the tile
A leak that came back after a repairThe patch missed, or the layer underneath is doneA look under the roofing, not another patch
One plane of the roof in bad shape, the rest decentA problem on one facetThe full facet
Leaks in more than one room, or a new spot every hard rainThe underlayment is doneShingle: a replacement. Tile that's still sound: a lift and relay

If your roof is in that last row, the longer answer is in repair vs replacement.

The money

What Drives the Cost

A full facet costs more than a patch and less than a full replacement. Past that, the number depends on your roof, and it comes in writing after we look.

If we find damaged wood once the roof is open, we photograph it and put the quantity and the price in writing for you to sign before it goes in.

At GAXThe estimate is free and in writing. A full facet repair comes with a 4-year limited workmanship warranty. On a spot repair, the warranty term depends on the scope, and it is written in your agreement.
How we handle it

We Tell You Straight

You get the same answer I'd give a family member. We walk the roof, show you what we found with photos, and tell you which repair we'd do and why.

If a spot repair will do

We'll say so, and that is what the estimate will be for.

If we recommend the full facet

We'll show you why, on your roof, with the photos.

If the roof is past a repair

We'll tell you that too. Several problems, or one problem on a roof that's clearly in decline, is a different conversation.

Questions

Frequently Asked

What is a facet on a roof?

A facet is one plane of the roof, between a ridge and an edge or a valley.

Is a full facet the same as a roof replacement?

No. It is one plane of the roof, redone. It costs more than a patch and less than a full replacement.

Will you do a spot repair?

Yes, when that is what the roof calls for. One problem on a healthy roof is a repair, and we'll tell you when that is the case.

Why did my last patch fail?

Most failed repairs are not bad work. They are good patches in the wrong place. Water enters at one point and travels before it shows, so a patch over the stain can miss the hole completely.

How much does a roof leak repair cost?

It depends on how big the area is, what kind of roof it is and what we find underneath. A full facet costs more than a patch and less than a full replacement. The estimate is free and in writing.

Does a tile roof repair mean new tile?

When the tile is still good, the same tile goes back on over new underlayment. Broken tile gets replaced.

Roof leaking, or a repair that didn't hold? We'll find the source, show you what we found and tell you straight whether it is a spot repair, the full facet or something bigger. We do four kinds of roofs: asphalt shingle roofs, tile replacement with new tile, tile lift and relay, and flat roofs.

Next in the library: Roof Leak Repair and Tile Roof: Repair or Replace?.

Get a Free Estimate →

Roof leaking?
We'll find the source and tell you straight.

(909) 819-8394